Question:
What is meant by
subprime mortgage crisis? Does it effect our Malaysia's economy?
What is meant by subprime mortgage crisis? Describe the
causes and risks of subprime mortgage crisis to the various markets in your
country. Which sectors of the economy were more severely affected? Which
sectors were relatively unscathed?
· apply basic
financial economic theory to explaining the workings of the domestic and international financial systems
· demonstrate
a working knowledge of the institutional framework for financing economic
activity
· demonstrate
an understanding of the operation of domestic money and capital markets and of
their linkages with global financial markets
Analyse the effects of changes in the private
financial system on economic activity.
Introduction
Sub prime
mortgage crisis has made the total number of job losses in United States for
year to date is more than 230,000.It has risen to more than five percent
compare to year 2006. (AEP, 2008)
This has happen because of credit crisis which started in the sub prime
mortgage market. The purpose of this essay is to discuss the meaning of sub
prime mortgage crisis and to analyze the causes and the risk to Malaysia ’s
various markets. In particular the focus is to the affected industry .Sub prime
mortgage started in United States and had caused a deep slump in global trade
including Malaysia.(Insap,2007)
Finally a discussion on the mitigation step taken and their effectiveness to
minimize the impact are presented in the essay.
The Definition of Sub prime
Mortgage crisis
The commencement of the sub prime crisis can be map out back to the time
when banks luring cheap short-term credit for sub prime borrowers a few years
ago. (Aseambankers, 2008) The low
interest rate environment has spurred increases in mortgage financing and
substantial increases in house prices. (Crouhy
et all.., 2008) The huge demand for these loans triggered the
miscalculation of risk and made it possible for any consumer to buy a house. (Aseambankers, 2008) Individuals were
speculating on the booming property market by buying multiple properties. The US federal
Reserve in turn had kept interest rates low, thus giving consumer high
reasonable price to own properties.(
Aseambankers,2008) The lender primary consideration for loan quality was
the ability to sell in the secondary market.(Gwinner & Sanders, 2008) A sub
prime mortgage is to establish a loan to unqualified borrower. Often these
borrowers have less or even no credit history. Sub prime mortgages often offer
interest- only loans. Borrowers are to repay the interest towards the beginning
of the loan tenure. (Amadeo, 2010)
Causes and risk of sub prime
mortgage crisis.
Sub prime mortgage market fall because of many reason involved. Researcher
had proved that the securitizers were to some extent aware of it. (Demyanyk & Otto, 2008) August 2007, the sub prime mortgage
problems started to surface in the financial market. The mortgage lenders were
unable to repay their debt since the housing price bubble busted and their
mortgage become larger than the value of their houses. (Insap, 2007) The fall of sub prime
mortgage happens because of the
unsustainable growth. (Demyanyk
& Otto, 2008). Once the loan had been granted to poor credit histories borrower
they are more likely to default. (Amadeo, 2010) Since the process of
granting a loan is easy. This has driven the property prices increases in some
areas given that the supply is the same. Banks and investors act procyclically,
extending credit more aggressively and competing for market share as collateral
prices rise.(Gwinner & Sanders, 2008)as
oppose to the declining income growth in these sub primes zip codes and their neighborhood. (Atif & Sufi, 2008)
In the first part of decade the interest rate were relatively low. Investor
is looking for a better yield income. Subprime mortgage offer higher yield than
standard mortgages and have been in demand for securitization.(Crouhy et all., 2008) Once the security
back by mortgage has been issued, it may be traded from one investor to
another.(Gallagher & Andrew, 2000)
Generally the seller of this security have no other involvement in the process
(meaning that investors rely purely on the mortgages as security and have no
resource to the lender should borrower default).( Hunt & Terry ,
2008) Secondary market transactions occurs thousand of times as investors
trade securities among themselves. (Gallagher & Andrew, 2000)
Between 2001 and 2006, between 60 and 80 percent of sub prime loans were
bundled into mortgage- backed securities and sold to investors in capital
markets (Gwinner & Sanders, 2008)
The theory of risk –return trade off is playing their part here, bank wouldn’t
take additional risk unless they expect to be compensated with additional
return. This axiom established the fundamental risk- return trade-off that
govern the financial market (Keown et
all, 1998)
Bank repackaged mortgages with different risk profiles and included a slice
of sub prime loans to enhance the yield. (Aseambankers,
2008) This in contrast with the bank lending model followed in most
emerging markets, where banks originate and holds the loans in their portfolios
fund them with deposits and retain the risk of default. (Gwinner & Sanders, 2008)
Effectively, the banks were giving loans to people who could not afford the
houses and selling the loans via all sorts of methods to other banks. The
problem was those low rates were not really profitable, especially when the Fed
was hiking up the lenders’ cost of funds at the same time. In order to boost
profits, the sub prime lenders started raising their lending rates. When the
interest rates were abruptly raised, monthly housing payments were raised
substantially. This made it difficult for homeowners to pay their mortgages,
they in turn started selling their homes. The subsequent effect was an
oversupply of houses, which led property prices to drop. Speculators were
losing money instead of making money. As a result, homeowners started
defaulting and declaring bankruptcy. Banks that are provided the financial
backing for these loans were affected when the borrowers started defaulting,
and the collateralized debt obligations and mortgage-backed -securities could
not be resold on the market. As a result, banks could not repurchase them as
investment anymore and were forced to sell the papers before prices
deteriorated further. In addition, banks refused to buy each other’s short term
debt resulting in a vicious cycle of forced selling. (Aseambankers, 2008)
The cause and risk of sub prime mortgage crisis
to the various market in Malaysia.
Primarily due to
lesson learned in 1997 crisis, most Asian countries also have much better
financial regulatory regimes in place than they did a decade ago. Their
commercial banks have better corporate governance and better internal risk
management and their corporate sectors have much lower leverage. Direct
exposure to both sub-prime and derivatives overseas is limited. (APCO, 2008) Broadly speaking, there has
been no sub prime mortgage lending in emerging markets. Instead, mortgage
lending is typically made on conservative terms to middle and upper income
households employed in formal sector, (Gwinner & Sanders, 2008)
and their backwardness has prevented Asian lenders from moving into complex and
sophisticated products.
The second
industries that is badly affected by the US sub prime crisis is the export
dependent manufacturing sector, was particularly vulnerable to the global
crisis. (Nambiar, 2009) Malaysia’s
export are closely tied to the US economy.(Insap,
2007) It has been observed, that the current crisis has had an impact on
Malaysia through the contraction of trade and FDI inflows (James et al.,2008)These declined have resulted in labor market
shocks which have led to retrenchments. (Nambiar,
2009)
The banking
sector lies at the very core of Asian financial systems, and the banking sector
has been largely unscathed. (Asian
Development Bank, 2009) The adverse
impact of global financial crisis on Malaysia has been limited and transmitted
through indirect, peripheral channels.(James
et al., 2008) Various financial indicators and banking sector data support
the contention that Asia’s financial system were well prepared for the crisis.
Nonetheless, stock prices in Asia were closely
linked to global markets and suffered badly in 2008. Although Malaysia has not been directly
impact by the sub prime mortgage crisis, steps are taken to cushion the related
industry. Next, the reader will be taken into the step taken by the Malaysia
government to minimize the impact of sub prime mortgage crisis.
Steps taken by
the government and central bank to mitigate the impact of sub prime crisis
The Malaysian
economy is expected to benefit from ongoing measures globally to stabilize
economic conditions through fiscal measures and loose monetary policy, as
growth is projected to rebound into positive territory in 2010. (Jagdev et all…, 2009) Malaysia government rolled out two
fiscal stimulus package, and interest rate were lowered to spur the economy, an
easing of monetary policy, and a relaxation of local equity requirement for
some foreign investor are among the incentive offered. (Asian Development Bank, 2009)
The first fiscal
stimulus package includes seven billion spending announced in November 2008 and
the Ringgit Malaysia sixty billion spending under the Mini budget announced in
March. Malaysia Prime Minister, Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak has committed an
extra Ringgit Malaysia
one billion per month until the end of 2010 to pump – prime the domestic
economy. The move is to lend additional crutch to the local economy to find
growth. (Kok, 2009)
In response to
the deteriorating domestic economy and slowing inflation, Bank Negara Malaysia ,
the central bank reduced its policy interest rate in steps from 3.5% at the
beginning of November 2009 to 2.0% in February 2009, and its reserve ratio for
commercial banks to a record low of 1% from 3.5% in November 2008. The second
is a trade weighted depreciation of the currency has further relaxed financial
conditions. (Asian Development Bank, 2009)
Other than the
financial stimulus and the interest reduction, the government is also
activating back the Corporate Debt Restructuring Committee was establishes during
the 1997/98 Asian Financial crisis to assist companies with debt problems. CDRC
(Jagdev et all., 2009)
In other
changes, the Government reduced the minimum stake to be reserved for Bumiputra
investors in initial public offerings to 12.5% from 30% and eased rules on
foreign investors buying stakes in Malaysian companies and property. (Asian Development Bank, 2009)
Evaluation of effectiveness of steps taken
by the government and Malaysia Central Bank
The year 2010 is
a recovery year. If recovery is strong, we may find ourselves achieving even
higher growth with the additional government spending. (Kok, 2009) Now we can see that there are sign of improvement in the
global economy. (Andrew, 2010)Malaysia
economy contracted by 5.1% in the first half of 2009, more sharply than
expected. On the production side, only services grew, while manufacturing
output, which is dominated by export–oriented industries, contracted sharply
and agricultural production declined. (Asian
Development Bank, 2009) Whilst on the stock market the benchmark index FTSE
Bursa Malaysia KLCI, was on rally last seen during the heydays of the Malaysian
economy in the early 1990s. Stock on Bursa Malaysia
rallied uninterrupted for 13 straight days as investor interest returned for a
number of reasons. The sub-prime mortgage crisis tragedy offered low yields on
stocks, real estate, bonds (Andrew, 2009)
Hence we have not seen the end of the crisis. (Andrew, 2010) It was early to conclude that the economy is
recovering or that the step taken by the government is effective. The better
outlook is underpinned by the fiscal stimulus and the expected recovery in
world trade and commodity prices. (Asian
Development Bank, 2009)
So far global
growth has been due to fiscal pump primp and historically low interest rate.
The steps taken by Malaysia’s government has seen the situation whereby the
financial markets are having a huge profit after the governments have rescued
the financial institutions by massive guarantees and zero interest rate policy.
(Andrew, 2009) One thing that could stop the recovery in
its track is a premature exit from stimulus spending. (Kook, 2009)
While on the
recovery side, CDRC (Corporate Debt Restructuring Committee) was reactivated as
a pre-emptive measure to help distressed companies during the current economic
downturn. This action to reactivate the CDRC may not be as efficient as the
small number indicates the corporate position now than during the Asian
financial crisis. (Jagdev et all..,2009)
Conclusion
In conclusion we can say that greed, fraud, problem resulting in lack
underwriting standards, incentive issues, failure to identify a changing
environment, poor risk management by financial institution, lack of
transparency, the limitation of extant valuation models and the failure of
regulators to understand the implications of the changing environment for the
financial system is the major reason for the fall of the sub prime
mortgage. Helping people to get a house to is a noble job, but without proper
mitigation to the risk will make the economy suffer, when the bubble bust. In
summary it is clear that U.S.
sub prime crisis has an effect to Malaysia , as an emerging market. This
essay has satisfied the purpose of defining and identifying the root of sub
prime crisis and the affect of it to Malaysia economy.
List of references:
Refer to author, kindly email to
norsanina@gmail.com
|
Declaration: By submitting this assignment
I declare that:
|
|
·
No
part of this assignment has been copied from any other person’s work except
where due acknowledgement is made in the text, and
·
No
part of this assignment has been written for me by any other person except
where such collaboration has been authorised by the examiner concerned.
·
I
hold a copy of this assignment which I can produce if the original is lost or
damaged.
|